13 Feb 2023

As death toll rises past 35,000, earthquake in Turkey and Syria now one of the greatest disasters in the 21st century


Patrick Martin


Cranes remove debris next to destroyed buildings in Antakya, south-central Turkey, Friday, February 10, 2023. [AP Photo/Hussein Malla]

The twin earthquakes that devastated south-central Turkey and northern Syria last Monday have produced a disaster whose toll in death, destruction and mass suffering is apocalyptic. Nearly 35,000 are dead, according to official figures, and that number is rising steadily. Entire cities have been leveled. And millions are now facing deprivation and further death in mid-winter weather, with aid that is grossly inadequate compared to the enormous need.

United Nations relief coordinator Martin Griffiths said that the reported death toll is likely to “double or more.” He added, grimly, “Soon, the search and rescue people will make way for the humanitarian agencies whose job it is to look after the extraordinary numbers of those affected for the next months.” According to the World Health Organization, nearly 26 million people have been directly impacted by the quake, and many of these will face the threat of hunger, disease and physical and psychological trauma.

The colossal scale of the disaster is difficult to grasp from the reports in the corporate media, which inevitably focus on a handful of successful rescues rather than on the thousands of bodies hauled out of collapsed buildings. Even the aerial photos of mass graves, taken by drone-mounted cameras, only give a glimpse of the dimensions of this tragedy. 

The tremor exploded along 300 miles of fault line—roughly the distance from Detroit to Chicago, or Paris to London. According to a NASA geophysicist, “This generated extremely strong shaking over a very large area that hit many cities and towns full of people. The rupture length and magnitude of the 7.8 earthquake were similar to the 1906 earthquake that destroyed San Francisco.”

Entire cities have been laid waste, some of them steeped in millennia of history. The ancient city of Marash, a crossroads of the Near East, now the modern city of Kahramanmaraş, with a population of 600,000, was the epicenter of the quake. The ancient city of Antioch, now the modern city of Antakya, population 400,000, has been virtually destroyed.

A few comparisons: the February 6 earthquake is already the fifth-worst natural disaster of the 21st century in terms of death toll, and will likely soon be third-worst, behind only the 2010 earthquake in Haiti, which killed as many as 316,000 people, and the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami, in which an estimated 228,000 people died across 14 countries, with Indonesia, Thailand, Sri Lanka and India hardest hit.

Those areas were among the poorest in the world: Haiti, the poorest in the Western hemisphere, but also the regions around the Indian Ocean where the tidal wave struck with full force. Turkey, however, is a country of middle income, with a large industrial base, a fully qualified candidate for entry into the European Union, although blocked for political reasons. Millions of Turkish workers make up a substantial component of the working class in Germany, Europe’s economic powerhouse.

The manifest failure of the Turkish government’s response is therefore not due to lack of access to technology or skilled labor or economic resources. It is entirely due to the financial considerations of Turkish and global capitalism, which reject spending on long-term infrastructure, such as ensuring buildings in major fault zones are able to withstand earthquakes, in favor of short-term maximization of profits.

The right-wing government of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan is more concerned about the potential political impact of the disaster than its human toll. A handful of building owners have been arrested to serve as scapegoats for systematic government corruption in the oversight of the construction industry, and to cover up the regime’s record of refusing to heed the warnings of scientists about earthquake dangers. There are bloodcurdling threats against looters, and reportedly more police sent to the region to suppress the population than relief workers to save lives.

While the Erdogan government certainly bears responsibility for this catastrophe, blame must be focused on the imperialist powers, and above all the United States, which has devastated the entire region in pursuit of global domination.

In Syria, the imperialist blockade has had such a savage impact that Griffiths of the UN said the world has “failed the people in north-west Syria… They rightly feel abandoned. Looking for international help that hasn’t arrived.”

US sanctions on Syria have blocked the flow of relief supplies, while US troops occupying parts of the country to control its oil production have stood by rather than provide aid to the victims of the earthquake. Amidst the devastation, the “mission” of the US military is to continue its regime-change operation, while subjecting tens of thousands of Syrians to barbaric conditions of imprisonment.

The pathetic sums offered in aid from the wealthy countries are dwarfed by their vast expenditures on the war against Russia over Ukraine and on the overall military build-up towards World War III, which would turn the entire world into a replica of the hellish scenes in the earthquake zone, and worse.

The US and European powers are presently flooding Ukraine with tanks and fighter jets, but when it comes to a massive social catastrophe, a pittance is offered. So much for the pretenses of “humanitarian” imperialism.

On Friday, the Pentagon comptroller confirmed that in its budget to be delivered March 9, the Biden administration will request the largest amount of military spending in American history, close to $900 billion. Meanwhile, the administration will provide $85 million, one-ten-thousandth that amount, for the relief of Turkish and Syrian survivors of the quake. Even this will be utilized in a way to advance the interests of American imperialism in both Syria and Turkey.

Only in the working class is there evidence of the enormous sympathy and solidarity of ordinary people for the plight of their brothers and sisters in Turkey and Syria. Aid workers from throughout the world have rushed to the scene, joining the tens of thousands of survivors seeking frantically to dig their spouses, children, parents and neighbors out of the mountain of rubble. Coal miners, who themselves risk death daily from cave-ins and explosions in Turkey’s notoriously dangerous mines, have trekked to the region to lend their assistance and expertise. 

But these efforts have been held back by the drastic shortage of the necessary equipment and technical expertise to conduct successful rescue operations—the responsibility of the major imperialist powers, which enjoy a near-monopoly in that sphere.

European powers prepare delivery of fighter jets to Kiev

Johannes Stern


The European powers used the European Union (EU) summit in Brussels at the end of last week, in which Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky participated as a guest, for a massive escalation of the war offensive against Russia.

Earlier in the week, at a meeting with British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz, Zelensky demanded the delivery of F-16 fighter jets. At the summit, numerous European leaders responded favourably to this demand, which vastly increases the risk of a comprehensive war with Russia and thus a third world war fought with nuclear weapons.

European Parliament President Roberta Metsola, who welcomed Zelensky in the European Parliament, stressed the importance of fighter jet deliveries to Ukraine: “Now, as the next step, states must consider rapidly deploying long-range systems and aircraft.” The European “reaction” must be “appropriate to the threat—and the threat is existential.”

Others spoke along similar lines. “All options are on the table, including the delivery of F-16 jets,” said Dutch Foreign Minister Wopke Hoekstra. And Estonian Prime Minister Kaja Kallas said, “If we had them, we would help Ukraine with all the means at our disposal.” She added, “The price to be paid in the face of Russian aggression increases with every hesitation.”

Although no European government has yet made concrete commitments, it is clear that the delivery of fighter jets is being prepared behind the backs of the population. At a joint press conference with EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen and EU Council President Charles Michel, Zelensky boasted that his visit to the UK had already brought decisions on the supply of long-range weapons and the training of pilots closer and was “really a step towards the supply of fighter aircraft.”

Zelensky said that at the EU summit, he was told by several leading EU representatives in bilateral talks that they were prepared to supply Ukraine with “the necessary weapons.” This included “aircraft.” He initially avoided going into concrete details of his talks in London, Paris and Brussels. When asked about them by a Ukrainian journalist, he said, “There are certain agreements that are not public but that are positive.”

The procedure is following the same well-known pattern. The delivery of battle tanks was also decided long before the public announcement. Germany, which has been portrayed as hesitant for a long time, is currently assembling an entire army of tanks against Russia. Following the initial announcement that 14 Leopard 2 battle tanks would be delivered to Kiev, the German government released the export permit for an additional 178 Leopard 1 battle tanks last week.

On Thursday, the German arms company Rheinmetall also announced that it is planning to deliver Lynx and Panther tanks to Ukraine. These are “the most modern armoured vehicles and battle tanks,” boasted the head of the group, Armin Papperger, in an interview with the Handelsblatt. The tanks could be built in Germany and Hungary, but they are “ready to build a plant for the production of the Panther in Ukraine.”

The tank deliveries are being advanced aggressively. During his inaugural visit to Kiev earlier this week, the new German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius announced that he would send the promised Leopard 2 battle tanks by the end of March. By this summer 20-25 Leopard I tanks will follow and another 80 by the end of the year. “The goal is to reach over 100 Leopards by the first or second quarter of 2024, which means at least three battalions—including the materials to be procured for spare parts and ammunition and, of course, training,” he said. 

Training for “600 sergeants” has also begun. And by the end of the month, there will be “more guided missiles, another five Cheetahs (self-propelled anti-aircraft guns), another five Dachs tankdozers and five Biber bridge-laying tanks,” explained Pistorius. 

German Chancellor Olaf Scholz also assured Kiev in his government statement before the EU summit of further massive arms deliveries and boasted that “in continental Europe,” Germany is “far ahead in the supply of weapons and ammunition” to Ukraine. “We have always worked closely and confidentially with our allies, whether it was on the delivery of self-propelled howitzers or multiple rocket launchers, to provide Ukraine with anti-aircraft weapons, or on our decision to deliver armored personnel carriers and, ultimately, battle tanks.” 

The Chancellor absurdly claimed, “We don’t make decisions that make NATO a war party.” This is an obvious lie. In fact, NATO has long been at war with Russia and is now escalating it. Representatives of the federal government openly say this. “We are fighting a war against Russia and not against each other,” Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock (Greens) recently said at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe in Strasbourg.

The fact that German imperialism, in particular, which already tried twice in the 20th century to subjugate Russia militarily, is again striking out against Russia underlines the real character of the German-European war policy. It is not about defending “freedom” and “democracy” but geostrategic and economic interests and the struggle for world power in the 21st century.

Germany's ruling class has long pursued the goal of rearming and organizing Europe under German leadership. The reactionary invasion of Ukraine by Russia, which was provoked by the NATO powers, has served as a welcome pretext. In his government statement, Scholz called for the necessary unity of “a geopolitical European Union” to be “an organising power in the multipolar world of the 21st century.”

The entire war summit in Brussels shed light on the reactionary character of the ruling class. It is responding to the deep crisis of capitalism and the growing revolutionary movement of the working class on the continent with a desperate turn to war and fascism. When Zelensky ended his provocative war speech in Brussels with the cry of the Ukrainian fascists “Slava Ukraini,” the entire EU Parliament rose to applause. 

Initially, the focus of the EU summit was supposed to be on tightening refugee policy. With the measures adopted at the summit, the EU is implementing the programme of far-right parties, such as the Alternative for Germany or the Italian ruling party Fratelli d'Italia. While in the Turkish-Syrian border area countless refugees fell victim to the earthquake disaster, the EU states committed themselves in the final declaration to the massive expansion of “Fortress Europe.”

Among other things, the EU reiterated its “full support” for the notorious border protection agency Frontex, also in order to “support increased repatriations.” In addition, “border protection capacities and infrastructure” will be expanded and additional “means of surveillance, including air surveillance, and equipment” will be made available. 

Opposition to this militaristic and anti-working class policy is developing all over the continent. In France, millions protested again over the weekend against President Macron’s planned pension reform. In Madrid, hundreds of thousands took to the streets for better health care. In the UK, millions of workers from different sectors have been taking part in a massive strike wave for months. In Germany, 11 million workers are engaged in collective bargaining and their demands are underlined by strikes and demonstrations. 

Strikes are also increasing in other European countries against job and wage cuts, and the devastating effects of inflation and the sanctions against Russia, which were strengthened at the EU summit.

11 Feb 2023

Disney announces 7,000 layoffs after exceeding Wall Street profit estimates

Kevin Reed


The media and entertainment monopoly Walt Disney Company announced 7,000 layoffs on Wednesday as part of a corporate restructuring aimed at increasing profits and improving investor earnings by cutting $5.5 billion in costs.

The Walt Disney Company announced it would be laying off 7,000 workers as part of a “strategic transformation,” announced by CEO Bob Iger on Wednesday, February 8, 2023. [AP Photo/Richard Drew]

In an earnings call with investors, Disney CEO Robert Iger presented the jobs massacre as cause for celebration, saying, “It’s time for another transformation.” Meanwhile, Iger said, “I have enormous respect and appreciation for the dedication of our employees worldwide,” even though 3 percent of Disney’s 220,000 workers will be losing their jobs.

The layoffs are connected with a reorganization that Iger said was necessary to dramatically cut costs that will “fully materialize” by the end of 2024. Of the $5.5 billion in cost savings, $2.5 billion are in “non-content” aspects of the corporation, such as marketing (50 percent), labor costs (30 percent) and technology (20 percent).

It is significant that Disney is taking advantage of the climate of mass layoffs hitting the technology, financial and other sectors that had huge losses in the past year to go after the jobs of its employees while the company had a profitable quarter.

The 7,000 job cuts were announced even though Disney reported revenues of $24.5 billion in the quarter that ended in December, an 8 percent increase compared to last year, and earnings rose to $1.28 billion from $1.1 billion a year ago, beating analysts’ projections. However, the all-important per share earnings category fell to 99 cents from $1.06 last year.

Uppermost in the minds of Disney’s investors is the fact that the entertainment company’s streaming service Disney+ lost 2.4 million subscribers in the last quarter, primarily with losses in India and parts of Southeast Asia, and this direct-to-consumer business lost $1.05 billion, which was also below Wall Street projections. Since it was launched in 2019, Disney+ has lost a total of $9 billion in the battle to attract subscribers in the overcrowded video streaming marketplace.

Like nearly every publicly traded company in 2022—among the exceptions are the oil and health care industries—Disney lost more than 40 percent of its stock value last year. Its major investors, such as Vanguard Group (assets under management of $8.1 trillion) and Black Rock (assets under management of $8.5 trillion), are demanding draconian measures aimed at getting their money back.

Typical of business news reports on the Disney reorganization plan is the one published by The Motley Fool which said, “But perhaps the most important piece of information from the report for dividend investors was news that the company plans to reinstate a regular cash payout later this year.” The report quoted Disney’s Chief Financial Officer Christine McCarthy at the investor call who said the dividend payout would occur at the end of 2023.

While thousands of employees are about to lose their only source of income, McCarthy told investors not to get too anxious about the size of their payouts. “The amount will likely be a small fraction of our pre-COVID dividend with the intention to increase it over time as our earnings power grows.”

Among the areas hardest hit by the layoffs are the Disneyland Resort theme park in Anaheim, California; Walt Disney World in Orlando, Florida; Disney cruise lines and the company’s international parks. In an email to hourly frontline workers, Josh D’Amaro, Disney’s Parks, Experiences and Products chairman, said, “As was shared on the earnings call, the company is targeting significant savings across all businesses, and the reorganization will result in necessary reductions to our overall workforce.”

The theme parks division was the most profitable of the Disney properties, with a revenue increase of 21 percent to $8.7 billion and a profit increase of 25 percent to $3.1 billion from a year ago. This was largely attributed to a 19 percent increase in theme park ticket prices in December. The average hourly wage of a Disney World employee is $18.88, according to the website payscale.com.

Iger, who has a personal net worth of $350 million, said his cost cutting plan—which reduces the structure of the conglomerate to three divisions: Disney Parks, ESPN and Disney Entertainment—will “re-establish the direct link between content decisions and financial performance.”

Late Wednesday and Thursday morning, Wall Street joined in Iger’s enthusiasm over the job cuts and pushed the $200 billion company’s stock value up sharply. However, the stock price fell later that morning when activist investor Nelson Peltz of Trian Fund Management withdrew his proposal for a more severe plan of cost cutting.

On behalf of all the major Disney investors, Peltz had launched a campaign to win a seat on the company board of directors so that his plan to attack the workforce with layoffs and increased exploitation of the remaining workforce could be forced through any lingering opposition within management. In the end, as Peltz told the Wall Street Journal, “He [Iger] said all the things that we would want him to do. Now they’ve got to execute.”

Corporate media reports have been ecstatic about Iger’s return as CEO in November, after the firing of Bob Chapek, as though he had some kind of magical powers to return Disney to profitability. Actually, Iger was brought back because he was seen by Wall Street as more reliable at wielding the axe than the man he had personally picked as his own successor in 2020.

This year is the centenary of the firm, which was founded by Roy and Walt Disney as Disney Brothers Studio in Hollywood, California, in 1923. It is significant that in all the reports about stock performance, earnings, dividends, layoffs and returning “creativity to the center of the company,” not a word can be found from Iger or the press about Disney’s 100th Anniversary Celebration.

It is a measure of the financialization of society, in general, and the takeover of the film and entertainment industry by billionaire parasites, in particular, that the legacy of the Disney brothers, who pioneered animated film and created the first sound cartoons ever made, has not even been mentioned.

However, the truth of what is going on is not lost on the workers and public at large. Responding to the layoff announcements, one New York-area Facebook user, who is obviously familiar with Disney’s treatment of its employees, known internally as cast members, said of Iger, “He needs to give himself a pay cut and increase all the cast members’ pay. No reason for layoffs other than greed by corporate.”

Another Facebook user said, “Greed! Disney go back to the recipe of Walt Disney and tunnel his inner vision of joy, happiness and magic!” And a former Disney employee commented, “Bob Iger I hope that includes mostly high paying executives and not the poorly paid hourly employees that do most of the work!!!”

Lights off on the Pandemic: Johns Hopkins University to retire COVID-19 tracker

Benjamin Mateus


After providing the public in the US and across the world three years of vital day to day information on the status of the COVID pandemic, Johns Hopkins University announced yesterday that they were retiring their highly acclaimed and well-appreciated Coronavirus Resource Center on March 10, 2023. Indeed, the end of this invaluable resource has significant implications for the present and for future pandemics.

Picture of the Johns Hopkins University of Medicine online Coronavirus Resource Center, February 10, 2023 [Photo: WSWS]

The site had been launched on March 3, 2020, by Johns Hopkins engineering professor, Lauren Gardner, precisely because there was a complete lack of any information or infrastructure for reporting such data. In September 2020, Gardner was named one of the “100 most influential people in the world” by Time for her efforts to develop the free, open website.

She noted at the time, “ I am deeply honored and humbled to have been individually recognized for an effort that has required the hard work and dedication of so many, including the team at the Applied Physics Lab, our students in the Center for Systems Science and engineering, our partners at ESRI, and multiple colleagues from across Johns Hopkins University, who have spent tireless weeks and months collecting, verifying, delivering, and communicating on this critical data, incoordination with officials from around the nation and the world.”

It can’t be overstated that in a pandemic, reliable data is of the essence for utilizing resources appropriately and directing plans rationally to contain the spread of disease and save lives and well-being. However, given that “forever COVID” is the stated policy of the Biden administration to the pandemic, reliable data is anathema to ending all pandemic measures.

With the carefully crafted and systematically implemented cover-up of critical COVID metrics led foremost by the White House beginning last year in the wake of the highly contagious and deadly Omicron phase of the pandemic, the public, as well as academic and government institutions across the globe, had no other recourse but to rely even more on the only credible source for data being provided by the Johns Hopkins COVID dashboard. In the wake of yesterday’s announcement that their tracker was shutting down meant not only had the curtain been drawn on any public health response against the pandemic, but the lights are about to go out altogether.

This comes as no surprise. It was almost one year ago, on March 14, 2022, that the World Socialist Web Site remarked that with the US public’s attention on the war in Ukraine, the entire state apparatus was shutting down daily reporting of COVID-19 cases and deaths. As the report noted then, “This nationwide rollback has been carried out with no public awareness, and there has not been a single national news report, in any major US news outlet, on these moves to shut down regular reporting.” These assessments have now been confirmed completely.

But by no means has the pandemic completed its assault on the population in the US (or anywhere else for that matter) despite President Joe Biden’s declaration last fall that the pandemic was over and with calls by both Democratic and Republican parties to wind down all public health emergency measures that provide people free effective and safe vaccines, rapid antigen tests and antivirals that can prevent the development of severe disease and Long COVID. In the wake of these measures, millions will be left without insurance and financial assistance all the while inflation is rapidly emptying saving accounts across millions of homes.

According to the CDC’s wastewater tracking, more than one-third of all sites reporting such data to the national public health agency have seen more than doubling of levels of SARS-CoV-2 up three-fold from a month ago despite the decline in official COVID cases reported to authorities. The seven-day average in deaths has been steadily climbing since the beginning of December having consistently remained over 450 deaths per day since the New Year.

In all, close to 1.14 million Americans have died from COVID, with 20,000 deaths just in 2023. If we tallied all the deaths since the BA.1 surge passed through the country in mid-February 2022, almost 190,000 people have died, an average of around 520 deaths per day. This is the new normal that American families have been asked to swallow. Such figures only confirm that the pandemic is far from over and calls for the complete dismantling of all public health tracking of infectious diseases is completely contrary to the social functions of state and national public health institutions and an abdication of their stated responsibilities.

Dr. Ellie Murray, epidemiologist at Boston University who spoke eloquently on the issue that COVID was far from becoming endemic, told the WSWS, “I’m really sad to see it ending, as it was a fantastic resource and demonstrated so well how people from all areas of expertise have something to contribute to public health and pandemic response. That said, I certainly don’t fault them for not being able to keep this going indefinitely. They were providing a valuable public health service. But public services are supposed to be provided by our governmental agencies and funded via our taxes. We never should have had to be in the position where JHU [Johns Hopkins University] needed to provide this service, no matter how grateful I and many others are to them for doing so.”

Devabhaktuni “Sri” Srikrishna, a San Francisco-based diagnostic expert and computer/network architect who was drawn into the 2014 unfolding Ebola crisis in Guinea, wrote in an email exchange regarding the JHU COVID tracker, “it was at times the world’s only trusted source of real-time, daily insight into the worldwide growth of the pandemic. It was relied on by people, governments and corporations alike ... I wish such a tracker existed and maintained for all infectious disease worldwide (such as Flu and Ebola) not just COVID.”

Greg Travis, who has carefully tracked COVID data and has been vocal on the need for reliable data and responsible public health response to the pandemic, wrote on Twitter, “And were’ done. I will stop processing Johns Hopkins data on March 10th when they shut down. I will continue to report COVID mortality from death certificates after that data, but be aware that death certificates suffer from undercount and at least a six month lag.”

In a brief telephone interview yesterday afternoon, Travis said, “It's just so tragic. What I saw, what I thought today about the JHU announcement, the main emotion it arose in me was deep sadness. It’s not unexpected, though. I wasn’t prepared for JHU to do it, but not surprising. I wonder though the timing and phrasing …”

Though Johns Hopkins never openly explained why they were taking their dashboard down, were there political pressures being brought to bear? Travis noted that JHU is reliant like any other tracker on reliable data. Even back in September of 2022, Axios reported that due to lack of real-time data and reliable figures, it had to drop testing numbers and provide less frequent updates.

In an email they wrote, “The changes are being driven by the declining quality and utility of pandemic data reported by state governments.” Data head for JHU’s Coronavirus Resource Center, Beth Blauer, had commented, “We have seen a dramatic shift in the way that state and local governments not only collect this data but share it publicly. That deeply constrains the way that we can actually report.”

Travis made a similar observation with regards to the American Academy of Pediatrics who had been tracking and publishing cases among children due to lack of reliable statistics from the centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). “But in July 2022 they announced they would not do it anymore because no one was giving them the information,” he added.

“It wasn’t because it wasn’t important, or they tired of it. They just couldn’t get the information. And this has happened to JHU. Since spring of 2022, case and death attainment has completely collapsed. Most of the US only provides, at best, data once a week. And entire states that didn’t report anything throughout the holidays. You have to gather the information from the ground. If that stops happening, you can’t aggregate it up. I’ve been tracking this information every day.”

Travis explained that such information is being deliberately withheld. “Our response to signals is to discontinue following those signals.” He explained that the superintendent of his son’s school informed the parents that in January 2022 they would stop collecting and sharing data on the number of COVID cases among children. “And that was the deadliest month for them during the pandemic. Meaning, we aren’t going to look anymore because the numbers were just too horrible. And families are being held responsible for making decisions about sending children to schools but lack any information to make appropriate decisions.”

He continued, “I recently sent an email to my schoolboard asking them what we can do to make schools safe as the world’s most powerful and affluent afford themselves at Davos.” During the highly publicized but secretive meeting between world leaders and billionaires, every pandemic measure was taken to protect the world’s elite.

“They said nothing - Thank you for your interest. That’s it. Nothing about how to increase ventilation. Nothing about CO2 monitors. Nothing about ultraviolet sterilizers or vaccines. These were things they employed at Davos to keep the participants safe. They had a lanyard that attested they were COVID positive or negative and they couldn’t get into the venue if they were positive.”

On the question of Biden and the ending of the pandemic emergency measures which are intimately tied to ending of all statistics on the state of the pandemic, Travis said, “It amazes me that when people talk to me about the Trump administration, and don’t see the same thing happening in the Biden administration. Their response to the pandemic has no ideology. It is only cruelty.”

He continued, “For a person, myself, who once called Biden a national treasure during Obama’s tenure, there is nothing dispiriting than to realize that a party I belonged to my entire life a party, that my late wife was an elected official in that party, when I heard what Biden said about the public health emergency, I realized that the Democratic party’s only guiding ideology was an ideology of cruelty for cruelty’s sake.”

He concluded, “I can’t imagine a politician that doesn’t want good news. The fact that they are shutting it down means the news is not good and the way they respond to bad news is to hide it.”

Death toll in Turkey-Syria quake nears 25,000, reports expose Turkish government’s criminality

Ulaş Ateşçi


As the earthquake disaster on the Turkish-Syrian border enters its fifth day, the death toll is set to reach a staggering 25,000. As of yesterday evening, total deaths in Turkey, where some 80,000 people were reportedly injured, exceeded 20,665, while deaths in Syria reached 3,500. Tens of thousands of people are thought to still be under the rubble in both countries, and at least 6 million people have been left homeless by the quake.

The Turkish Catastrophe Insurance Pool (TCIP) announced having received over 30,000 “damage reports” after the quake that devastated ten cities in Turkey. In Syria, where the first international aid only reached Thursday, over 900 buildings collapsed and about 2,000 buildings were damaged, according to the Gazete Duvar.

People bury their loved ones, victims of Monday earthquake, in Adiyaman, Turkey, Friday, Feb. 10, 2023. Emergency crews made a series of dramatic rescues in Turkey on Friday, pulling several people, some almost unscathed, from the rubble, four days after a catastrophic earthquake killed more than 20,000. [AP Photo/Emrah Gurel]

One of the most striking images of the social catastrophe in the region was of the mass grave where thousands of people were buried in Adıyaman. The situation is similar in other cities hit by the earthquake.

Journalists working for media outlets outside the government's control and social media users are reporting that there are still problems in the affected provinces in meeting basic needs such as electricity, water, natural gas, shelter and sanitation.

An aid volunteer in Hatay's Antakya district, one of the hardest-hit areas, told the World Socialist Web Site that only on the third day of the earthquake did heavy equipment begin search and rescue operations, in a district which looked “as if an atomic bomb had been dropped.” Before that, people used picks and shovels to dig out those under the rubble, and critical hours were wasted.

Turkish rescue workers carry Ergin Guzeloglan, 36, to an ambulance after pulled him out from a collapsed building five days after an earthquake in Hatay, southern Turkey, early Saturday, Feb. 11, 2023. Emergency crews made a series of dramatic rescues in Turkey on Friday, pulling several people, some almost unscathed, from the rubble, four days after a catastrophic earthquake. [AP Photo/Can Ozer]

The aid volunteer said there is still no large-scale operation except for search and rescue teams from a few Istanbul district municipalities. There is still no phone reception and no Internet. Only a few tents have been set up at the entrance to the city, and most people are still spending the night on the streets with fires. A cholera outbreak has begun.

Official figures show that yesterday Turkey surpassed the death toll threshold of the great Marmara Earthquake of 1999. This 7.4 magnitude earthquake that struck nearly a quarter of a century ago killed 17,480 people in five provinces, according to official reports. But some unofficial reports put the actual death toll at over 50,000.

However, the 2023 earthquake, centered in Kahramanmaraş, came after decades of massive advances in industry and construction technology worldwide and in Turkey, improved earthquake regulations, and persistent warnings from scientists.

The Union of Turkish Bar Associations (TBB) has filed a criminal complaint against “authorized and responsible contractors and officials who took part in the construction of the buildings that collapsed in the earthquake, and those who approved and failed to inspect the projects of the collapsed buildings,” and demanded they are prosecuted for “intentional homicide” and “negligent homicide.”

It is clear who should be put on trial. Responsibility for this massive social crime belongs to the government of President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan in particular, and to the entire state and political establishment that failed to take necessary safety measures.

The Erdoğan government's response to the earthquake has focused more on covering it up than on promptly coming to the aid of earthquake victims above and below the rubble.

Speaking yesterday in Adıyaman, facing enormous social anger and opposition that could not be suppressed Erdoğan said, “There have been some shortcomings in this process, but our state has rushed to the rescue of citizens with all its means.” He then admitted, “It is a fact that we could not speed up the interventions as much as we would have liked.” Nevertheless, he attacked those who criticized his government's bankrupt response to the earthquake disaster as “political looters.”

With the monthly poverty line for a family of four around 29,000 TL (US$1,540) and a minimum wage of 8,500 TL (US$450), Erdoğan announced that earthquake victims will receive only 10,000 TL (US$530) per household.

This is a continuation of the government’s policy. It has not allocated resources to save tens of thousands of lives by building earthquake-resilient cities in the 10 provinces hit by the quake, or in Istanbul, where scientists expect an earthquake of over 7-magnitude in the coming years. Instead, it has poured hundreds of billions into the banks, the major corporations and military spending.

As scientists have underlined, no party of the capitalist establishment has mobilized or campaigned against the government’s official neglect policy towards coming earthquake disasters in Kahramanmaraş or Istanbul.

Geologist Prof. Dr. Naci Görür, who has drawn attention to the growing danger of earthquakes in the region, especially in the last three years, demanding immediate measures are taken, again pointed out the danger to Istanbul after Monday's earthquake. “The probability of an earthquake [in Istanbul] within 30 years, at any time since 1999, was 62 percent. We have spent 23 years. 62 percent probability has increased to around 70 percent. We are now in overtime.”

Since the earthquake, Erdoğan has repeatedly claimed that it was impossible to be prepared for such a massive disaster in order to deny his government’s responsibility. Both the analyses of scientists and the reports of Turkish state institutions themselves refute this argument.

Prof. David Alexander, an expert in emergency planning and management at University College London, told the BBC, “The maximum intensity for this earthquake was violent but not necessarily enough to bring well-constructed buildings down.”

Despite improvements in earthquake regulations in 2018, there was corruption in practice, Prof. Alexander added. “In most places the level of shaking was less than the maximum, so we can conclude out of the thousands of buildings that collapsed, almost all of them don't stand up to any reasonably expected earthquake construction code.”

The BBC report pointed to Turkish government “construction amnesties… effectively legal exemptions for the payment of a fee, for structures built without the required safety certificates.” Pelin Pınar Giritlioğlu, Istanbul head of the Union of Chambers of Turkish Engineers and Architects' Chamber of City Planners, said, “Up to 75,000 buildings across the affected earthquake zone in southern Turkey have been given construction amnesties.”

The last “construction amnesty” was in 2018.

A January-June 2022 report by the Turkish Environment, Urbanization and Climate Change Ministry stated that a total of 244,607 unsafe buildings were identified in 81 provinces across Turkey, of which 2,512 were in Hatay, 1,765 in Kahramanmaraş and 1,239 in Adıyaman. In 10 provinces, including these three, the number of buildings officially said to have been completely collapsed is around 6,500.

In Istanbul, a city of 16 million inhabitants, 84,000 unsafe buildings were identified. Hundreds of thousands of people living in these buildings are vulnerable to an imminent earthquake.

Despite this, according to the daily BirGün, during the earthquake disaster district municipal councils in Istanbul, governed by Erdoğan’s AKP, convened and “green areas were opened for construction in the February session of the municipal councils.” This means further reducing the already very limited gathering areas after earthquakes.

The Disaster and Emergency Management Presidency (AFAD), affiliated to the Interior Ministry and coordinating the earthquake response, was revealed to be completely unprepared for a disaster directly affecting 13 million people in Turkey alone. AFAD, which responded to the earthquake with only around 8,000 search and rescue personnel, confirmed that it was understaffed in its own 2019 report.

According to T24, the report noted that “the division of duties, authorities and responsibilities within the institution has not been made sufficiently clear,” “structural and functional integration has not yet been fully achieved due to the merger of three institutions that were previously in operation,” and “some search and rescue technicians cannot take active roles in search and rescue services.”

AFAD's budget was cut by one-third in 2023. Its response to the magnitude-6 earthquake in the northwestern city of Düzce on November 23, 2022, already made clear the inadequacy of the institution and criminal neglect of the government. In its report on this 2022 Düzce earthquake, in which no one died under the rubble, AFAD expressed its own shortcomings as follows:

After the earthquake, Turkey Disaster Response Plan (TAMP) could not be put into effect because disaster groups and institutions were not sufficiently prepared. Since TAMP could not be implemented, disaster management turned into chaos and confusion, leading to confusion of duties and authorities. Decisions could not be taken properly due to lack of communication. Disaster response groups were not able to manage their resources effectively, which resulted in inadequate response.

This led to the late and inadequate response to the 2023 Kahramanmaraş earthquake, resulting in tens of thousands of preventable deaths and leaving tens of thousands more trapped under the rubble.

10 Feb 2023

Mental Health Illness: A Global Tragedy by Design

Graham Peebles


After being ignored and scoffed at for generations, there is now growing awareness of the legitimacy and seriousness of mental health illness; of the debilitating, often suffocating, impact conditions such as depression and anxiety have on individuals, as well as the broader societal impact.

Mental health illness is a modern-day tragedy of global proportions; while individual patterns and circumstances vary, widespread interwoven causes within contemporary society function as major trigger of unhappiness, low self-esteem and discontent. Values, so-called, socio-economic and educational methodologies, including competition, comparison and conformity, the relentless agitation of desire, the importance of ‘success’ and focus on pleasure, all create insecurity, discontent and division; and where there is division of any kind, within the individual or society, conflict inevitably follows.

In June 2022 the World Health Organization (WHO) published its most detailed report on the topic: ‘The World mental health report: Transforming mental health for all’, designed, “To inspire and inform better mental health for everyone everywhere.” The data shows that around one billion people suffer from some form of mental health illness, or one in eight of us; “a staggering figure” [rising annually] which the UN agency rightly illustrates, “is even more worrying, if you consider that it includes around one in seven teenagers.”

Shocking as they are, these figures serve as little more than pointers to the scale of the problem. Most people do not live in developed countries with relatively well-resourced health services, but in poor or desperately poor nations, where little research is carried out and where there is often no mental health support. WHO report that, “around half the world’s population lives in countries where there is just one psychiatrist to serve 200,000 or more people.”

Where treatment is available, it is often unaffordable or inaccessible; consequentially “most people with diagnosed mental health conditions go completely untreated,” and so they suffer, often agonizingly, and in many cases for decades. Mental health illness destroys lives, feeding employment, education and relationship issues or failures; alcohol and drug addiction, and in extreme cases self-harm and suicide. According to WHO (2019 figure), every 40 seconds, of every day, someone somewhere in the world dies of suicide, many more attempt it; among under 25 year olds it’s one of the leading causes of death.

A perpetual state of agitation

Parallel with growing awareness of mental health, there is a good deal of talk in western nations now (commonplace in the Orient for eons) about meditation; and the Buddhist inspired discipline of mindfulness; of focusing completely on the task or activity at hand.

Meditation (from the Sanskrit dhyana) is, strictly speaking, not an activity: it is a direct experience of reality, in which the division between experiencer and experience has ceased to be. However, what is commonly regarded as mediation is more often than not some form of concentration or visualization exercise. Concentration on the breath, on an imagined form or a particular word/form of words – a mantra of some kind. All of which, whilst perhaps not qualifying as ‘meditation’, is extremely positive for mental fitness.

In the same way that physical health requires our active engagement (exercise, diet, sleep etc.), if we are to create a healthy mind, particularly given the enormous stresses and demands of life, we need to take responsibility for it. To pay attention to the activity of the mind, to learn to focus. This means becoming aware of the movement of thoughts, which much of the time takes place unconsciously and is saturated in conditioning. Psychological/sociological conditioning is ubiquitousbeginning from birth – before in fact – and continuing relentlessly until, or unless we wake up and realize that what we take to be ‘I’ or ‘me’, is nothing more than a conditioned structure, an image, built around a set of accumulated ideas; opinions and views – about the world, other people and ourselves, poured into the mind and unconsciously absorbed.

Such constructs are inherently inhibiting and divisive, adding to the belief that we are separate, from one another, from the natural environment, and from that which we call God. The socio-economic ideology of the age strengthens this sense of separation; cruel, violent and unjust it denies compassion, promoting values based on selfishness, personal ambition/achievement at the expense of the collective good, and the health of the natural world. Economic insecurity is, for the majority, the daily reality, how to pay the rent/mortgage, for instance, and avoid destitution; separation and isolation creates an environment in which fear, most commonly experienced as anxiety or stress, can and does flourish.

Consumerism, which constitutes the life blood of the economic system, is offered as a way to alleviate the inflicted pain. Poisonous on numerous levels it requires discontent and desire to be constantly maintained, ensuring that the mind is kept in a perpetual state of agitation; driven by longing, moving from one feeling induced thought to another, never settled. In order to move beyond the endless buffeting of fluctuating, often painful feelings and transient thoughts, we need to create mental fitness and strengthen the mind. A powerful way of doing this is through meditation and mindfulness.

The impact of meditation on stress

Over the years various studies have been conducted investigating the impact of meditation. In October 2022 Practical Psychology discussed research showing “that meditation can help thicken the prefrontal cortex of the brain,……[which], not only increases our ability to complete tasks…but also reduces aging in the brain.” In addition, “Meditation reduces chatter in the monkey mind. We stop focusing on our problems and start observing what is happening around us,” thus reducing mental agitation; a 2020 study undertaken by the Center for Healthy Minds (CHM) at the University of Wisconsin-Madison on a Buddhist monk, found that his brain was ‘eight years younger’ than his 41 years; adding “to a growing pile of evidence that meditative practice may be associated with slowed biological ageing…….[which] makes sense biologically, because stress is a thing that causes ageing,” and meditation helps to reduce stress.

New research, reported in The British Medical Journal (BMJ), which looked at the impact of meditation on the gut health of 37 Tibetan Buddhist monks, and 19 secular residents, revealed that gut bacteria associated with the alleviation of mental illness “in the monks differed substantially from those of their secular neighbors……suggesting that meditation can influence certain bacteria that may have a role in mental health.”

Becoming mentally aware, learning to consciously work with the mind, to focus on the task at hand, and not allowing the mind to wander off; strengthening and expanding one’s ability to concentrate, facilities mental fitness, reduces the impact of daily stress and worry, and, as the Buddha taught, creates joy: “ it is a great good to control the mind; a mind self-controlled [focused] is a source of great joy.” The simple act of sitting quietly for 15 minutes or so, once or twice a day, shifting our focus away from the external chaos and turning within, has been demonstrated (by CHM and others) to aid this process.

Like all exercise regimes, discipline and consistency is needed, but once a rhythm of reflection is established, it quickly becomes part of the daily routine. In choiceless observation, the great Indian philosopher J. Krishnamurti maintained, “every form of conditioning is dissolved,” allowing transformation within the brain to take place; healing, in which, as the study on the 41 year old monk demonstrated, the brain cells themselves are rejuvenated, allowing peace of mind to spontaneously come about.

The world we are living in, with its constant noise, demands and pressures; the destructive ideologies, divisions and unjust systems, works against such inner quiet and mental well-being. Indeed, contentment and unconditional happiness is the enemy of the dominant corrupt economic paradigm, founded and reliant as it is on consumerism and desire. Constant longing (through dishonest advertising and relentless marketing) is its aim and is the guarantee for misery, depression and anxiety/stress. Within such a mentally and physically unhealthy environment, it is crucial that individually we recognize the dangers, which are real and potent, and, where possible and within our own limitations, act to safeguard our own well-being, mental and physical, and of course, the two are inextricably connected.

Former NATO general to be next Czech president

Markus Salzmann


At the end of January, Petr Pavel won the run-off election for the office of Czech president. The former NATO general is considered to be a zealous warmonger against Russia. Like the country’s right-wing government led by Petr Fiala, he advocates an intensification of the conflict with Russia in the Ukraine war.

Petr Pavel at the end of his term as chairman of the NATO Military Committee 2018 [Photo by NATO / flickr / CC BY-ND 2.0]

The arms deliveries made so far to Ukraine were not enough, according to Pavel. On this issue, he sees “really no reason to set limits,” the military leader told the AFP news agency. The West should provide Ukraine with all types of weapons except nuclear ones, he said.

“Ukraine cannot fight such a tough opponent without tanks, drones, artillery and longer-range missiles, and perhaps not without supersonic aircraft,” Pavel said. He openly criticised European countries that, in his opinion, were not delivering enough heavy warfare equipment to Ukraine. He said that “more courage” was needed to deliver modern weapons. In this context, he also called for the dispatch of F-16 fighter jets and that Ukraine be allowed to join NATO as soon as possible.

In his view, Western governments should have reacted more decisively, i.e., intervened militarily immediately after the secession of the Donbas. He advocates direct intervention by NATO ground troops against Russia. He would also agree to the deployment of NATO soldiers to protect humanitarian corridors and to a no-fly zone.

He has also gone onto the offensive against China. As soon as he was elected, Pavel telephoned Taiwanese President Tsai Ing-wen and invited her to a personal meeting. Until now, the Czech Republic has officially supported a One-China policy and did not maintain diplomatic relations with Taiwan.

The Ukraine war was the central topic of the presidential election. The massive price increases resulting from the sanctions against Russia are hitting the population harder than almost any other country in the EU, with the exception of the Baltic states.

Broad sections of the population, who must bear the burden for the war, reject the policy advocated by the future president and the government. In the presidential election, however, this opposition found no expression.

In the first round of voting, former Prime Minister Andrej Babiš and Pavel were on equal terms, with all other candidates far behind. In the run-off election on January 27 and 28, Pavel then prevailed with 58.2 percent of the vote against his opponent’s 41.6 percent. Eleven of the country’s 14 districts went to Pavel and in the capital Prague he got 76 percent of the vote. Babiš won only in rural areas.

The result does not signify support for Pavel's fanatical war policy; rather, it is a distorted expression of anger with the entrepreneur and billionaire Babiš. He is seen as the epitome of corruption and the subordination of all sectors of society to the interests of business. In his government from 2017 to 2021, he passed several austerity pacts, made concessions to companies and the super-rich, while at the same time giving free rein to the pandemic.

Babiš's attitude towards the Ukraine war was somewhat more cautious than Pavel's. Before the second round of elections, he even answered “no” in a TV debate to the question of whether he would support the Baltic states or Poland in the event of a Russian attack. After the broadcast, however, he quickly distanced himself from his statement.

In the meantime, Babiš has congratulated Pavel on his election victory and advised him, “Forget Babiš!” However, the oligarch is not expected to retire quietly from politics. His party, ANO, is still the strongest in parliament and expects to win the election in three years’ time.

All the defeated candidates from the first round called for votes for Pavel in the run-off. Danuše Nerudová and Pavel Fischer even attended a Pavel election rally and provided advertising space.

There is expected to be close cooperation between the president and the government when the term of incumbent President Milos Zeman ends on March 8 and Pavel is sworn in a day later. Although Pavel ran as an independent candidate, he says he voted for the SPOLU party alliance, which agreed to Petr Fiala (ODS) as prime minister, following the last parliamentary election in 2021.

Fiala leads a five-party coalition held together by their opposition to Babiš. It is dominated by right-wing, conservative parties and extends to the Pirate Party. Like the government, Pavel advocates the introduction of the euro, austerity measures and rearmament both at home and abroad.

Pavel's background as a military man and his aggressive stance towards Russia also made him the preferred candidate of the EU and its member states. Ursula von der Leyen, head of the EU Commission in Brussels, was the first to congratulate him. Slovak President Zuzana Čaputová made a point of travelling to Pavel's campaign headquarters in Prague to congratulate him personally.

Pavel stands for the growth of militarism that is being vehemently pursued within the EU. On his election posters he presented himself with the slogan “Experienced diplomat and war hero.” This included a military medal next to his portrait.

Born in 1961 in western Bohemia, Pavel comes from an officer's family. He was educated at the military high school in Opava, after which he studied at the Army Military College in Vyškov. From 1983 he served with the paratroopers in Prostějov and quickly rose to become commander of an elite unit. During this time he became a member of the Stalinist Communist Party. In the late 1980s he attended a military intelligence school.

After the so-called Velvet Revolution in 1989 and the introduction of capitalism, Pavel was one of those political opportunists who used their contacts in the military and intelligence services to further their careers. Only a few years after the fall of communism, Pavel was an advocate of the NATO war in Yugoslavia and was himself deployed there.

From 2012 to 2015, he was chief of the General Staff of the Czech Army, then, until 2018, Chairman of the NATO Military Committee, the highest military position in the Western defence alliance. Pavel was the first representative from a former Warsaw Pact state to hold this position.

Already, the effects of the EU's war policy are dramatic for the population, which is suffering from soaring inflation. Housing is becoming a luxury. According to a report by the consulting firm Deloitte, the price per square metre for housing in the capital Prague is the equivalent of €15. According to the report, a 70-square-metre flat costs more than €1,000 a month, about 25 percent more than a year ago. At the same time, the average monthly salary is around €1,600.

Buying a flat, which was very popular until a few years ago, is now hardly possible. Rising prices per square metre and mortgage interest rates have quadrupled in five years, posing extreme problems for working families.

Electricity and gas prices rose more than in almost any other country last year. In the first half of 2022, electricity prices increased by 62 percent, gas by 71. Even households with average incomes already have to spend 65 percent of their income on rent and energy costs. Government leader Fiala declared last year that the government did not have the means to compensate for these price increases for households.

The more than 300,000 Ukrainian refugees in the country are particularly affected by poverty. Of them, 58 percent were living in poverty in December. Six months earlier, this figure was 49 percent. While the government never misses an opportunity to mention the suffering of the Ukrainian population at the hands of Russia in order to justify its war policy, there is no proper official support for the refugees in the country.

At the same time, banks and corporations are making record profits thanks to massive government support. As the statistics of the Czech National Bank show, Czech banks posted a net profit of the equivalent of €4.4 billion in 2022, according to current figures. Compared to the previous year, this is an increase of €1.5 billion.